psycheoma ꒰ᐢ. .ᐢ꒱₊˚⊹

metacomedies: definitions for isekai stories and other genre fictions

last modified 1 day, 4 hours ago

It’s been two months. Let’s get to it.


I’ll probably pick this topic back up when I have more years under my belt and a better equipped mind. Or maybe I won’t. Who knows…

I’ve been reading a lot of genre fiction this year. I should lay out my understanding of what that means before I tackle anything else. That’s part of the intent of the post, so I’ll delay if only in the interest of padding. Shameless, I am shameless, I am!

The publishing world divides fiction more or less into two categories: literary fiction and genre fiction. A genre is a series of traditions and tropes and clichés and narrative tools and shortcuts and pieces of atmosphere and intent that are used to create pieces that are so closely in dialogue with one another that they’re interbreeding in the public highway, and the fine for this misbehavior is always a loss of prestige, genre fiction included. There are many noble families of fiction: horror with its screaming victims and bloody monsters (sub-dividable into branch families such as paranormal, religious, cosmic, psychological, etc.); romance, with its sweeping declarations and profound feelings (bodice rippers, romantasies, dark romances, fluffy light romances…); the allied houses of fantasy and science fiction, with their not-human but yes-people, their speculative constructed worlds, their exploration of subsequent consequences.

And that is how I would seriously define speculative fiction: the creation of a constructed world and follow-through on logical consequences of its rules and/or norms. I think it’s a good model for considering edge cases like the first book in the Baru Cormorant series, which I read late last year, I think? and which I found to be really good. Baru Cormorant has no magic or science in it, at least not in the beginning, only speculative geopolitics that still feel detached from our rules of natural physics and of social physics (to call the field by a name that reduces it, though, even with that caveat, I still find the term very fun to deploy). But if the geopolitics are the speculative part, then Baru Cormorant doesn’t need magic to be speculative. Easy. That’s one definition down. I’m fucking great at these!

Literary fiction is what genre fiction is not. There’s an assumption that genre fiction is stale and by-the-numbers and repetitive, which is not wrong but does lack nuance. However, if that is genre fiction, then literary fiction, then, is new and fresh, or at least it tries to be. In the same way, it can be said that genre fiction is a prisoner of its building blocks, and so literary fiction must be free. Literary fiction can be about anything, but only a few times: repetition is the marker of genre. Once literary fiction writers repeat themselves too often, they create a genre, and this is usually received in the literary world kinda like a teenager announcing a pregnancy. Literary fiction must be real and grounded where genre fiction is ridiculous and unbelievable, and it must be light of step where genre fiction trods on with heavy doses of exposition. It’s impossible to speak of a “surprise genre”, but I think it’s telling that the most literary of fantasies (or more accurately, the most fantastical flavor of literary fiction) is magical realism, which is defined by never really explaining what the fuck just happened.

I don’t think magical realism is a type of fantasy, by the way, or at least it’s not a type of genre fantasy — it’s a genre, inasmuch as literary fiction has subgenres. (Genre fiction and literary fiction aren’t true opposites, more of a yin-yang thing where each has a bit of the other. Is the Dao dialectical? Probably a hotly debated topic). But magical realism isn’t speculative. Speculative, here, means that it attempts to map out something that doesn’t exist. Magical realism is more like poetry. The supernatural elements in magical realism are blended into the natural ones, and never explained, and taken for granted, because they’re not exercises for the reader: they’re expressive. They’re here to paint an emotion that can’t be described with words. Poetry does this all the time. You don’t think a raven seriously spoke to Poe, or you don’t seriously think that Poe thought a raven spoke to him, but you also don’t construct a world in your imagination where ravens speak on the regular. Unlike what you’d do if you were reading a fantasy book where a raven starts speaking. Right? Because it’s poetry. It’s not constructing, it’s expressing.

Poetry does all that, and literary fiction and magical realism follow suit, because there are emotions and feelings that can’t be said in words. You have to be guided to them, at best, but most likely you just have to stumble upon them. Language is not tailored to expressing their subtleties, and it shouldn’t have to be, and it can’t ever be, because nothing we could understand as language could express these feelings succinctly and not constrain them. Language communicates by being spoken, which sounds like a truism, but let me paraphrase a post on the internet I like:

“Elephants have a particular noise that communicates ‘there are bees nearby, we must leave immediately’.”
“Wow, I wish humans had that too.”
“We do, the noise is ‘there are bees nearby, we must leave immediately’.”

But you still try to imagine a noise that can contain all the little bits of the experience of bees being nearby — the buzzing, the fear of their sting, the cuteness of bees, the fact they’ll die to defend the hive. And you can’t. Because describing those elements appropriately, to the level humans understand them and to their complexity, means to spend the words I just spent — maybe more! — conjuring small pieces of information in someone else’s mind like pixels. Less would mean a lower resolution. A dog’s mind probably looks like the E.T. Atari game.

Earlier this year, I had a unit on Madame Bovary, and the professor shared an anecdote: Flaubert was approached to publish an illustrated edition of another novel of his. He rejected it. His reasoning was (if I may paraphrase): “Are you f—king crazy? I worked so hard to put the words together to describe things in my work, so they conjure all the right emotions and a bunch of the wrong ones, and you’re gonna let some dipshit with a pencil just hand my readers the images and waste all my work?” (c.f. Rien, who only reads picture books because he doesn’t want to imagine things and risk picturing something not “canonical” to the story).

Poetry is a useful comparison point when talking about literary fiction. There was a really long time in human history (in certain places, of course) where writing as art was, non-negotiably, only poetry. Theater did come around eventually and even that was quite poetic for some time, and in the cultural shadow of westernmost Europe, longform prose as an art form emerged from serials and lowbrow comedies and an idea that some, nowadays, call “unfiction”, that is, fiction masquerading as non-fiction. Prose was a bit of a bastard child. Eventually it dominated over poetry; this was for a million reasons, like everything, but I like to point out among them the fact that our societies very quickly became extremely secular and material and cynical, and grew to disregard the spiritual and metaphorical and uncertain. Which is neither a bad nor good direction for them to take, in my opinion. Maybe one that can be harmful if not moderated, but so can the opposite… at this scale, ethics don’t really exist as more than a suggestion or a scolding or the bridle of a horse. Right? Right.

But I think literary fiction’s high esteem is because it’s the invented inheritor to poetry. Poetry has been subsumed by literary fiction in a lot of ways. If you want a historical metaphor, think of how a king nowadays is only really a very rich guy who knows who his family was to the umpteenth generation: the triumph of the bourgeoisie over the aristocracy and the absorption of the aristocracy into the bourgeoisie. The divine right of kings and the need to keep metric have both gone the way, not of the dodo, but rather of the panda, still alive but bred in captivity because material circumstances discourage reproduction.

And I say the invented inheritor because literary fiction isn’t one thing. It’s whatever is fancy. That’s the true definition of literary fiction: the stuff that’s fancy. The shit that makes you fancy and intelligent to read. Look at how many places the ideas of genre fiction and literary fiction overlap! Are mid-century dystopias genre fiction? Is magical realism genre fiction? Is epic poetry genre fiction? If reading it is fancy, no it’s not. It’s not that genre fiction is for the intellectual lumpenproletariat (because by now we know plenty of smart people like genre fiction), but rather, that literary fiction is for the people who aren’t that.

Part of this fanciness is that literary fiction, by virtue of being the genre of trailblazing, is at its best challenging and unique — though I don’t think good works of literary fiction are hard to appreciate at all unless you’re unwise.

(Not unintelligent: unwise, cowardly, intimidated by reputation. Many very good works of literary fiction are pretty fucking stupid. Many are comedies! Literally just funny! But people think art is a straight line forward to The Thing It Means, when really any work of art is like a park that you go one way and then the other and yet the rest of the park exists. Mediums force art to be ordered to different extents, but art, to me, always has an element of omnipresence to it. Art isn’t about one thing distinct from all other meanings, so much as it is a tableau that you can approach from many angles and understand in many different ways).

Where was I? Fancy. Right. Part of literary fiction, definitionally, to me, is also that it’s what is held right now in high esteem. You can’t just hold something in such high esteem that it stops being genre fiction, but, again, we have a lot of examples of fiction that could be considered arguably both genre fiction and literary at the same time. Often, they’re the codifiers, the ones everyone imitates: you could totally argue Lord of the Rings is literary fiction, for example, because while it didn’t invent fantasy, it formalized it. I think the strongest case is still magical realism, though, because Lord of the Rings is extremely speculative, and speculative constructions and exercises for the reader are in the tradition of non-fiction (particularly instruction) and thus of “bastard” prose, while poetry (and by consequence literary fiction) are the opposite.

These are the classifications as they exist. I mostly want to introduce a new axis, or maybe a new model to try to interpret this classification through.

In my opinion, it could be interesting and fun as an exercise (see, exemplary of nonfiction) to try to define genre fiction as fiction that pushes boundaries of content, while literary fiction pushes boundaries of format.

See, I think written art has two parts: the format and the content. The content is what is being said, and the format is how the author is saying it.

If I say genre fiction, you’ll probably think of possible futures and of mystical worlds. And, yes, speculation is part of but not the totality of the exploration of possible content. But you can also think of romance or of horror, which are genres that deal with heightened emotions, indescribable ones, and you might wonder why those aren’t literary. And the answer is that they don’t innovate in the realm of the format. They present new content: new people falling in new loves or dying in new ways. New descriptions of the infinite facets of lived experience. But the words and the techniques they use are well-worn. You open the book, and you read chapters consisting of paragraphs of description and dialogue and narrated inner thoughts in more or less equal share: there is a situation that requires resolving, a cast of characters, and this all takes place in a world that is complete enough to be livable in. There’s an assumed “correct” chronological order, and an order in which to read the words and the chapters which is obvious to the intended audience. There are certain types of characters that are focused on; there are archetypes and repeated events and old ideas mixed in with the new and utilized in novel ways. And so on, and so on forth.

Literary fiction innovates in the format. The line between format and content blurs all the time. For example, Madame Bovary was novel in a lot of its description and tone, but it is still a chaptered novel, which was already a well established idea in its time: part of how it pushed format was because it dared to be a tragedy about a normal woman, rather than a queen or something. But I think that when content is dictated by format, using one type of format to describe the wrong type of content is still innovative. This sounds foreign, but that’s mostly because nowadays, content dictating format is an alien idea. You can write anything in any shape. This wasn’t always the case, and many works pushed boundaries until we got to the point we’re in now. (And also changed material circumstances, etcetera).

The platonic example of a literary work, then, could be something like Ulysses by Joyce, or Hopscotch by Cortázar, or If on a winter’s night by Calvino. You can make arguments for a lot of the stories we consider obviously literary to still be literary under this standard. Some of them have their arguments weakened by the change in standard, or indeed by the creation of a standard, a requirement, when previously what is literary and what is not was designated by tradition and lack-of and prestige. That’s why I’m only really proposing this as a mental exercise and not a serious way to classify things. I’m not crazy like that.

A classification I do want to suggest more seriously — or at least a label — is the “metacomedy”.

I have been reading a lot of genre fiction. Earlier this year, it was more of the standard, traditionally published fantasy bricks, but as winter took its licks I retreated to web originals and indie-published fiction. I have been reading isekais and litRPGs and transmigrations and regressions and timeloops and progression fantasies and satirical danmei .1 I have. There’s little prose quite as bastard as these. I think all of these microgenres crosspollinate so frequently that they need a bit of a rallying flag. I think they’re — well, they’re not a singular movement, what ever could be, but they’re a lot of closely allied movements moving in the same directions and with the same aims. Decades ago, the label of speculative fiction started being used to cover the alliance between unrealistic genres like fantasy and science-fiction; genres which increasingly crossbred, as demonstrated here (or here, if you want to remain on Wikipedia).

So if all of these web original microgenres, transmigrations and systems and regressions and the like, are so closely interlocked that the Venn diagram of their reader-bases is a circle, then I think it could be useful to have a name for the whole damn thing. And my proposal is the term “metacomedy”.

Most, if not all, of these stories are “meta”. “Metacomedy” is technically a subcategory, or at least a relative, of “metafiction”, a term from which we get the colloquial adjective “meta”. I would define “meta” (adj.) like this: “Said of a text that references its own existence as a text or attempts to transgress the barrier between its contents and the audience (the “fourth wall”).” What people generally mean when they say something is “meta” is that there’s a multi-layering of fictional constructions going on.

For example, let’s take a “LitRPG”, a genre characterized by a numerical system patterned after videogames and tabletop roleplaying games and maybe even board and wargames, though I’ve seen less of that. It proposes worlds where qualities like strength and intelligence are measurable in numbers, but that’s not an accurate description: rather, it constructs an artificial system of numbers that imposes itself onto reality and warps it around itself, and then it lets its characters explore and exploit the system and attempt to understand it as needed to tell the story.

(There’s always an impression that rather than the systems creating their realities, they take a preexisting reality and disrupt it, an impression which is there because it’s true: these worlds subjugated by numerical systems are otherwise based on our real world, so they come first. The general vibe is “corset constricting stomach fat” and is equally if-you-like-it-you-love-it-if-you-don’t-you-hate-it).

This is speculative, but it’s not just speculative: it’s a wholesale reference to other mediums, written in such a way to be understandable immediately to those with knowledge of these other works, and most importantly, it’s (to some extent) satirical of those elements. “What if videogames were real?” is a question whose answer is always preempted by “It would suck, because…” or “It would be awesome, because…”. They express the absurdities of a foreign format.

The same with other types of metacomedies. Isekais and transmigration (which are sort of the same thing but don’t have to be2) express absurdities of full-immersion fantasy by contrasting them with a representative of the mundane, cynical, material world. These absurdities aren’t always condemned, sometimes in fact they’re preferred to the original world, but they are always expressed. There is always an adjustment. The real world is defined by what the fantasy world is not.

Metacomedies don’t even need to point out the absurdities in a preexisting real genre. It’s well documented that there’s no such thing as a “villainess stock character” in romantic visual novels, for example; rather, the genre of villainess metacomedies is aping one specific game, and then drawing conclusions from neighboring works of romance, fantasy, and romantic fantasy, to create a spoofable genre from its base ingredients. It preempted the target of its own satire. If villainesses did not exist they would need to be created! (And they didn’t, so they were!)

Comedy, in the sense of “fiction designed to make you laugh”, is a major element of metacomedies, but there are many works of metacomedy that aren’t funny at all. My intent with the term “comedy” is more theatrical. A tragedy is designed to teach a moral, while a comedy is designed to entertain and satirize. “Metacomedy” is really just a specific way of saying “satire” (or, more accurately, “cross-genre and cross-format satire”). “Metasatire” didn’t roll off the tongue as well as metacomedy did, though, so comedy as a descriptor stuck.

Additionally, many metacomedies wouldn’t describe themselves as satirical in any way, because they’re doing something new and interesting: they’re exploring the premise almost to the point of deconstruction. “What if videogames were real?”, etcetera. But all metacomedies express the surreality of Genre traditions, formatting and content both. “What if real people had to deal with this?” they ask: what if a real person found out they were a character in a bad romance novel, like in Cyan Wings’ Devil Venerable Also Wants to Know? What if a real person had to suddenly abide by numbers and skills and perks and penalties and digital rules of simulation of all kinds as if they were a character in a videogame, like in Miles English’s Bog Standard Isekai series? What if a real person with a real psyche was behind the villainess mask and the entire cliché was as much a farce on the inside as it feels like it is from the outside, like in any given villainess story you’d like to quote, like in Mary Doe’s Proud to be the Villainess?

Metacomedies are sort of the anti-literary fiction. They bury themselves in so many tropes and clichés and schematics and tools and preexisting ideas that they come out the other side with something new. I think that’s fun, even if it’s not something inherently prestigious. It’s not elegant at all. I think fighting the fight to make metacomedies chic, to make literary respectability ‘fetch’ happen, is kind of pointless. They might become respected someday, maybe, but their point isn’t to be respected, because right now they’re not really inheriting from poetry at all. They’re speculative in the purest sense. The preexisting traditions they alternatively exalt and skewer are a trellis upon which the… the tomatoes of art can flourish. So to speak. So to fucking speak. I don’t know.

So I’ve been reading metacomedies. A lot of them. I’ve also been reading stuff I don’t think I consider metacomedic. Like, we’ve been over this. Genre is not an instruction set for the future, it’s a description of the past, a transcription of an echoing, repeating dialogue, something where people often use the same words. It’s a tradition and a moment. Genres are less about their subject matter than they are about their moment. Or maybe they’re the halfway point of their subject matter and their moment. And of the preexisting dialogue, the knowledge of previous works in the genre (and also all of human art and history somewhere, like all other non-Genre art). Three-way baby. But there are many works published right alongside metacomedies that I don’t consider metacomedies. There’s a lot of fanfic that’s metacomedic and a lot that’s not, for example.

I guess the definition, outside time and space and art movements, has to involve the purposeful and explicit referencing of artistic format and content exactly as what they are, at least to the audience’s eyes. The characters don’t need to know what a videogame is, but the audience does. And to some extent, there must be a manipulation or alteration by the characters of the expectations and rules and norms of this referenced imaginary hypotext… And there is the layers of it.

It’s important that it’s in layers. Watch the Device Theory. Six hours of amateur speculating on the mechanics of a borderline-magical realism Alice-style “other world” fantasy work, straight to the dome; fuck you, you’re in my house now. I don’t think I need to say that Undertale and Deltarune are metacomedies. That feels self-evident. (Is Yume Nikki literary fiction? I mean, to me it is…) I don’t know if Homestuck is a metacomedy. I kind of feel like it must be, but it lacks the spirit. Homestuck is doing stuff that’s too complex and esoteric to its hypotext for the audience to parse it, and I think there being a clarity to the exploration of the hypotext’s previously undiscussed dimensions is like, an important part of the spirit of the thing. It’s maybe an unorthodox metacomedy. I can accept that.

But the layering is important, and in that, Homestuck is exemplary. Deltarune through the lens of the Device Theory interpretation also is.

Otaku nerd shit over. In metacomedies, there is a layer that’s the literal lived reality of the characters, and if it wasn’t a metacomedy, the next layer up would be reality, but because it is, there’s an in-between non-literal layer. Like, this layer (and here I differ from Molly Stars’ verdict) is not necessarily diegetic. In fact, in most works it’s not diegetic. It’s a direct stabilized breach of the fourth wall. I like Devil Venerable to explain it: there is Wenren È and the rest of his world, and then there’s the realities of Abusive Romance and the other books that narrate the stories of Wenren È’s material reality, but Abusive Romance and its readers aren’t real. Three layers. Deltarune’s worlds and characters and their diegetic realities, then an “inter-getic” layer of menus that connect the fictional characters upwards, and then the real world. Stabilized breaches of the Fourth Wall. The other world, the transmigrated person and their “original universe”, and then our real, actual reality.

And I say it’s a “stabilized” breaching of the fourth wall, because regular breaches of the fourth wall are unstable. The illusion can’t be maintained. The characters can acknowledge that they’re not real, but they can never really speak back to the audience. The illusion that a character has realized that they’re not real is just as much an illusion as the idea that they were real in the first place. A character is not capable of realizing or knowing or doing things. A character is a shape. It’s a vector. It’s an idea. If an actor drops a line, that’s at worst a “character break”, and at best, an improvisational papering of the fiction over the breach. To stabilize the break in the fourth wall, you have to subsume it into the fiction. There has to be a fake fourth wall to be broken, and then the real one can remain intact — but the fake one being referenced may be consensually confused with the real one by the reader. Suspension of disbelief, and all.

I dunno. Obviously the layers are part of all meta-fiction to some extent, but the metacomedies are about the layers in a way in which other meta-fictions might not be… But also, ultimately, my diagnosis isn’t like… “Well, you have X, Y, and Z symptoms, so you’re a metacomedy”, so much as it is a new word to describe a specific moment in art history. Which is this one.

And yes, this too is art history. You best start believing that anything creative, regardless of prestige, can be a work of art; you’re already making one!



I don’t have anything else to say. Hi guys! I really enjoyed Canto X! I was skeptical at first, but the second and third parts of it won me over. Autistic love is real and will save us all…

It feels really weird to post this and finally be able to use the term metacomedy in casual conversation. I’m always prone to Gregory Berryconing and severe idiolect activities — I think a lot about the Unabomber getting caught because he insisted on saying “eat his cake and have it too” rather than backwards. That’s how you’d catch me if I ever did a crime. I’d say some shit only I ever say or talk about and you’d be on me like a shark smelling blood. Anyway, I try to restrict myself until I can fucking point to a definition, and now I have this post and maybe someone else will also start saying this shit. (Unlikely, but a boy can dream).

I was planning on making a post ranking villainesses years ago, and I got an e-mail about it a few months back, so that may or may not be next. Either that, or a project I’ve been working on throughout the month that’s functionally a whole bunch of little SCPs all together. You guys like reading SCPs, right? You like the SCP Foundation, right? These aren’t SCPs, they involve copyrighted material, but if you like SCPs, you might get a kick out of these. (…they’re abnormalities, ok).

Point: I don’t have plans for posts talking about metacomedies that aren’t villainesses that I have read. So! Here’s some that I read through, or am keeping up with, and enjoy, and haven’t mentioned before on my blog (I don’t think). Let’s do them in alphabetical order.

A couple of these (guess which?) were recommended to me by Kami. Everyone say “thank you Kami”, she’s great!

…Well, I don’t have any more life updates. I mean! I do. But I’m not gonna get ahead of myself. I’ll talk about things when I’m ready.

Until then, and as always:

thank you for reading!

  1. A Chinese genre of gay romance novels between men published independently and semi-anonymously on the internet. They often, but not exclusively, take place in cultivation fantasy or “xianxia” settings, comparable to high fantasy or heroic fantasy stories from the west.↩

  2. there’s no actual difference between an isekai and a transmigration story other than cultural and of translation, but it could be fun to use isekai for when the character travels to another world in their original body vs. transmigration when the character reawakens in a foreign body as a different person. This isn’t how it’s currently used and I doubt my idea will take root, but it’s fun↩

#2026 #longform #✨ #🌕